review comment

[W4415] Game Theory

Departments: Economics

Professors: Prajit Dutta, Tim Huh, and Tumer Kapan

October 06, 2007

Huh, Tim
[W4415] Game Theory

The reviews above that state Tim Huh's propensity for errors in his class notes are absolutely accurate. His lectures are so full of errors because he chooses to derive the formulas in class as opposed to having them done beforehand, which makes no sense since he already has a hard enough time ending class on time. He rushes through irrelevant topics during his lectures, leaving his students baffled when it comes time to do homework, since nothing on the homework even resembles the examples he gives in class. I found the TA sessions to be much more helpful since the TA actually goes over the important things, rather doing what Tim Huh does, which is deriving some obscure equation that has no use but the professor finds to be "interesting". Going to his class and then attempting the homework is similar to being taught how to drive a car and then being expected to know how to fly an airplane.

Workload:

Homeworks that don't take too long if you go to office hours but would otherwise be impossible if you actually tried to do them using only what Tim Huh teaches in class. He expects his students to have a full masterful understanding of the subject matter when all he does in class is teach us the most obscure examples in class. Finishing his homeworks without the help of the TA is impossible unless you have already learned the material before hand.

July 01, 2006

Kapan, Tumer
[W4415] Game Theory

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

My understanding is that this is Professor Kapan’s first time teaching, and I feel he did ok overall. However, two areas need signifigant improvement. The first is his lecturing skills. He often goes too fast, and assumes levels of knowledge on the part of the students that may or may not exist (for example, infinite series in calculus). And he doesn’t take questions well during lectures, he seems to get tense when students ask him to repeat or clarify things, which is intimidating and makes people less likely to ask questions again.
But the second, more important aspect are his exams. Simply put, they were insane. The midterm was challenging but perhaps not off the map. But the final was nonsense; it was by far the most difficult exam I’ve taken here, and I don’t think another week of prep time would have left me better prepared. And he grades very, VERY harshly, unlike the TA who graded our homework with a check, check plus, and check minus system. So the homework did not prepare us well for the exams, nor did it give us any idea of how harshly we would be graded. If possible, I'd recommend against taking this course with him, especially if you want to learn game theory (unless you are a math major). Course is HIGHLY theoretical.

Workload:

(Summer Section) Reading is fairly light.
4 problem sets, reasonable, very challenging midtem, INSANE final.

September 06, 2004

Dutta, Prajit
[W4415] Game Theory

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

Professor Dutta uses his own book and he follows it to the word literally. This is actually wonderful for a class that could get confusing at times. His class is very organized and tests are fairly easy if you read the book, especially sections in the book that do not work out full solutions.

Workload:

Problems sets, midterm, final

Directory Data

Dept/Subj Directory Course Professor Year Semester Time Section
ECON / ECON ECON ECON W4415: Game Theory Fuhito Kojima 2012 Spring TR / 4:10- 5:25 PM 1
ECON / ECON ECON ECON W4415: Game Theory Qingmin Liu 2012 Fall TR / 6:10- 7:25 PM 1
ECON / ECON ECON ECON W4415: Game Theory Prajit Dutta 2010 Fall MW / 10:35-11:50 AM 1
ECON / ECON ECON ECON W4415: Game Theory Prajit Dutta 2009 Fall MW / 10:35-11:50 AM 1
ECON / ECON ECON ECON W4415: Game Theory Prajit Dutta 2008 Fall MW / 7:45- 9:00 AM 1
ECON / ECON ECON ECON W4415: Game Theory Prajit Dutta 2007 Fall MW / 10:35-11:50 AM 1
ECON / ECON ECON ECON W4415: Game Theory Prajit Dutta 2006 Fall MW / 10:35-11:50 AM 1
ECON / ECON ECON ECON W4415: Game Theory Prajit Dutta 2005 Fall MW / 9:10-10:25 AM 1
ECON / ECON ECON ECON W4415: Game Theory Levent Kockesen 2004 Fall MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1
ECON / ECON ECON ECON W4415: Game Theory Levent Kockesen 2002 Fall MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1