Review Comment

[EESC V2100] Earth's Environment System: Climate

September 04, 2018

Tenen, Dennis Silver_nugget and Truong, Linh
[MATH V1101] Calculus I and [EESC V2100] Earth's Environment System: Climate

m

Workload:

j

January 08, 2015

McManus, Jerry Silver_nugget and Shaw, Tiffany
[EESC V2100] Earth's Environment System: Climate

This class is amazing. It's a lot of work and takes up a ton of time but McManus and Shaw are both the kindest and most caring professors I have ever had. The two are willing to meet with any student at any time, which is hard for them because they split their time between Morningside and Lamont. I don't consider myself a science person and at times the material got a bit tricky, but McManus and Shaw are always willing to explain something over and over again. Overall though the material isn't too bad and the professors are amazing.

The labs take up a lot of time, but overall the TAs are fair and are also always willing to explain the material or why they took off points somewhere

GO TO OFFICE HOURS. Can't stress that enough. Don't take this class if you don't have time to devote to office hours and asking questions outside of class.

Workload:

11 labs, 8 hw assignments, midterm (a little tricky), final (very easy)

December 23, 2011

McManus, Jerry Silver_nugget
[EESC V2100] Earth's Environment System: Climate

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

Jerry McManus is seriously the nicest professor I have ever encountered here at Columbia. He is so willing to help his students and genuinely wants to see them all do well. He teaches the second portion of the Climate class (the first professor is great too). He sometimes is a bit sidetracked/hard to follow, but if you ask him questions, he is great with clarification. Also go to his office hours! He will sit with you through every single question you have and make sure you're understanding everything. He is very understand and overall a great teacher. Climate overall can be a difficult class because it requires a good amount of memorization, but if you attend lecture, it's relatively simple to follow.

Workload:

Not bad - 8 HWs (very simple, a few problems - 10%), a midterm (30%), final (40%) and labs (20%). Some readings that are not required, but are very helpful.

December 30, 2010

McManus, Jerry Silver_nugget, Smerdon, Jason , Hale, Sarah (TA) , Henry, Gene (TA) , and Chiu, Soyee (TA)
[EESC V2100] Earth's Environment System: Climate

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

This class has to be my biggest disappointment at Columbia thus far. The class was, at times, pathetically redundant with the Frontiers of Science curriculum, which itself was often pathetically redundant. The class's makeup also seemed to be averse to learning Environmental Science itself, as most students were either Sustainable Development Majors or were there for the Science Requirement. Thirty minutes of a class were once spent on explaining why the seasons occur, and amazingly several members of the class were still confused. The subject matter was tragically interesting - the first half of the semester, taught by Jason Smerdon, dealt with Atmospheric Circulation and Weather Systems. Although at times he came off as shallow, Smerdon was extremely charismatic and held the class's attention quite well. The second half of the semester was taught by McManus, and although he came off as more intelligent than Smerdon, his lectures sometimes rambled and his class notes were not helpful with studying, consisting mostly of pictures and scanned scribblings. His lectures focused on Deep Ocean Currents but also spent way too much time on the same 3 ideas about Climate Change.

I would have liked to call this an "easy" class due to its sparse and repetitive subject matter but this was not an "easy" class. Even if you pay attention and take notes in class, and even if you read the optional readings from the textbook, I still cannot say you're going to get an A in this class. The weekly labs were a shitshow. The TAs came disastrously unprepared to labs, which as the semester progressed often required downloading glitchy software that the TAs did not understand how to use and also failed to tell us to download in advance. Most labs consisted of inputting data into Excel and making graphs over and over again. It did not matter if you understood the subject matter (which was often a painfully basic grasp of Climate Change), but a few formatting errors in Microsoft Excel or Word could cost you one or two letter grades. The TAs often didn't respond to emails sent regarding formatting yet penalized students harshly on formatting when grading labs. Their grasps of labs' actual content were also maddening, and they were often bitter and angry when politely challenged. If these people are on the front lines of environmental change and study, we are fucked.

It is seriously unfortunate that this class is a requirement for an EESC degree, as this completely turned me off to the entire department

Workload:

extremely redundant and painful weekly labs worth 30% of grade, P/F homeworks worth 10%, 30% midterm, 30% final

Directory Data

Dept/Subj Directory Course Professor Year Semester Time Section
EESC / EESC EESC EESC V2100: Earth's Enviro Syst: Clim Syst: Earth's Environment System: Climate Gisela Winckler, Kevin Anchukaitis 2012 Spring T / 4:10- 7:00 PM 1
EESC / EESC EESC EESC V2100: Earth's Enviro Syst: Clim Syst: Earth's Environment System: Climate Jerry McManus, Tiffany Shaw 2012 Fall T / 4:10- 7:00 PM 1
EESC / EESC EESC EESC V2100: Earth's Enviro Syst: Clim Syst: Earth's Environment System: Climate Peter Schlosser, Gisela Winckler 2011 Spring T / 4:10- 7:00 PM 1
ENSB / EESC ENSB EESC V2100: Earth's Enviro Syst: Clim Syst: Earth's Environment System: Climate Mingfang Ting, Gisela Winckler 2010 Spring MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1
EESC / EESC EESC EESC V2100: Earth's Enviro Syst: Clim Syst: Earth's Environment System: Climate Jerry McManus, Jason Smerdon 2010 Fall T / 4:10- 7:00 PM 1
ENSB / EESC ENSB EESC V2100: Earth's Enviro Syst: Clim Syst: Earth's Environment System: Climate 2010 Spring T / 4:10- 7:00 PM 0
EESC / EESC EESC EESC V2100: Earth's Enviro Syst: Clim Syst: Earth's Environment System: Climate Mark Cane, Jerry McManus 2009 Fall T / 4:00- 7:00 PM 1
ENSB / EESC ENSB EESC V2100: Earth's Enviro Syst: Clim Syst: Earth's Environment System: Climate Peter Schlosser, Mingfang Ting, Gisela Winckler 2009 Spring MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1
EESC / EESC EESC EESC V2100: Earth's Enviro Syst: Clim Syst: Earth's Environment System: Climate Richard Cullather, Jerry McManus, Arnold Gordon 2008 Fall T / 4:00- 7:00 PM 1
EESC / EESC EESC EESC V2100: Earth's Enviro Syst: Clim Syst: Earth's Environment System: Climate 2007 Fall MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1
EESC / EESC EESC EESC V2100: Earth's Enviro Syst: Clim Syst: Earth's Environment System: Climate Richard Cullather, Arnold Gordon, Tina Flierdt 2006 Fall MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1
ENSB / EESC ENSB EESC V2100: Earth's Enviro Syst: Clim Syst: Earth's Environment System: Climate Stephanie Pfirman, Yochanan Kushnir, Peter Schlosser 2005 Spring MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1
EESC / EESC EESC EESC V2100: Earth's Enviro Syst: Clim Syst: Earth's Environment System: Climate 2005 Spring MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1
ENSB / EESC ENSB EESC V2100: Earth's Enviro Syst: Clim Syst: Earth's Environment System: Climate James Hays 2004 Fall MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1
ENSB / EESC ENSB EESC V2100: Earth's Enviro Syst: Clim Syst: Earth's Environment System: Climate Yochanan Kushnir, James Hays, Arnold Gordon 2004 Spring MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1
EESC / EESC EESC EESC V2100: Earth's Enviro Syst: Clim Syst: Earth's Environment System: Climate James Hays, Arnold Gordon, Nili Harnik 2004 Fall MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1
EESC / EESC EESC EESC V2100: Earth's Enviro Syst: Clim Syst: Earth's Environment System: Climate Sidney Hemming, Martin Visbeck, Jean Lynch-Stieglitz 2003 Fall MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1
ENSB / EESC ENSB EESC V2100: Earth's Enviro Syst: Clim Syst: Earth's Environment System: Climate Sidney Hemming, Stephanie Pfirman, Martin Visbeck, Jean Lynch-Stieglitz 2003 Spring MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1
EESC / EESC EESC EESC V2100: Earth's Enviro Syst: Clim Syst: Earth's Environment System: Climate Yochanan Kushnir, James Hays, Arnold Gordon, Peter Menocal 2002 Fall MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1
ENSB / EESC ENSB EESC V2100: Earth's Environmental Systems: the Climate System 2002 Spring T / 4:10- 7:00 PM 0
EESC / EESC EESC EESC V2100: Earth's Environmental Systems: the Climate System: Earth's Environment System: Climate Stephanie Pfirman, Arnold Gordon, Harry Jr, Martin Visbeck 2002 Spring MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1
EESC / EESC EESC EESC V2100: Earth's Enviro Syst: Clim Syst: Earth's Environment System: Climate Sidney Hemming, Stephanie Pfirman, Harry Jr, Martin Visbeck 2001 Spring MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1