Review Comment

Human/Earth System

January 05, 2012

Eisenberger, Peter Silver_nugget
Human/Earth System

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

There aren't enough things that I can say to dissuade you from taking this class.

REALLY -- JUST DON'T TAKE IT.

First of all, why is this class even in DEES? Science is almost entirely absent from this course. If you're seeking a class with FACTS, this is not the course for you... I don't understand how a physics person can talk so much and provide such little support for his arguments.

The first week or two is all about cutting down the class to under 20 students - if you get chosen you will feel special and like you should definitely stay in the course, even if your instincts keep telling you to drop it. Listen to your instincts, and get out while you can!! The rest of the semester will be made up almost entirely of Eisenberger lecturing about a bunch of bogus ideas that are really not realistic or relevant at all. Don't believe it when this class is sold to you as a seminar - IT'S NOT! You will, however, be graded on participation. So if you stick it out make sure you figure out some way to participate in class. Although you should not expect your arguments to be taken seriously - Eisenberger always has something to say to try to prove you wrong. And he really will not drop it until he feels like he has. Even if it means making arguments such as evolution being just a "theory" (I mean, really? in a science department of all places?!).

Eisenberger will tell you that he is open to opposing ideas, but I honestly don't think this is true. Which means you will have to tailor your paper to something that he agrees with. That's a minimum of 25 pages of bullshit! The worst part is that his ideas are ridiculously naive and downright unrealistic, and his confidence in the human race's ability to figure out all of its problems just by "following the Golden Rule" is saddening. Don't worry if you don't get to shed a tear for our future during the first couple of weeks though, you will be subjected to an entire semester of repetition, so you will have plenty of chances. Maybe Eisenberger is one of those who believe that if you repeat things enough, people will start to believe you. (nope, didn't work... at all.)

One thing I liked about the course was the guest lectures - we had a really good one from Peter DeMenocal. It was kind of hard to concentrate when Eisenberger was falling asleep in the middle of it though... If you don't find your guest lecturers interesting, then why invite them to speak in class in the first place?!

Despite my evident disagreements with Eisenberger's teaching style/content/etc., the worst part definitely had to be the TA. Suparna Dutta was hands down the worst TA I have ever had at Columbia. She was rude during class (putting her head down during student presentations, acting visibly annoyed when she didn't approve of the topics, answering her phone during lecture) and over e-mail. And her and Eisenberger were evidently not on the same page whatsoever. Good luck getting help from her, but don't try Eisenberger either, he won't answer your e-mails.

Workload:

Readings, weekly postings on discussion board, 2 presentations on paper topic, 25-50 page final paper

January 13, 2011

Eisenberger, Peter Silver_nugget
Human/Earth System

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

Most absurd and incredible class I have ever taken.
Peter has strong disagreements with the way education is done so his teaching style doesn't exactly fit the mold of the 1.5 hour class twice a week, but the contents of his brain and life are worth poring over and questioning.
The development of knowledge and the brain over time, overtaking the time scale of natural evolution, and how this will effect our concept of the future and "sustainability" (such bullshit in every other SD class I've taken, but here the term is really carefully examined), and basically just about anything else you want to talk about will be covered. The world is going to be a scary place in the near future, probably unrecognizable to us. Peter helped me see just how much humans are going to need to take over in managing the planet, and how scary it might be.

Workload:

Weekly posting on anything you want, one final paper (25-50 pages), again on anything you want. WORTH IT.

March 02, 2008

Eisenberger, Peter Silver_nugget
Human/Earth System

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

An excellent class with very interesting and provocative concepts. Professor Eisenberger is an engaging and passionate lecturer on the topic of the interaction of man and his environment. Some of his theories are a little out there but it forces you to push the limits of what you think is possible, sane, moral etc.He made the effort to meet with every student in a group and if you like stuff about space exploration,mass extinction events, lasers, supervolcanoes and cyborgs this is the class for you.

Workload:

A semester long research paper(25 or more pages), plus 2 presentations.

Directory Data

Dept/Subj Directory Course Professor Year Semester Time Section
EESC / EESC EESC EESC W4917: The Earth/Human System Peter Eisenberger 2006 Fall TR / 9:10-10:25 AM 1
EESC / EESC EESC EESC W4917: The Earth/Human System Peter Eisenberger 2004 Fall MW / 1:10- 2:25 PM 1
EESC / EESC EESC EESC W4917: The Earth/Human System Peter Eisenberger 2002 Fall TR / 4:10- 5:25 PM 1