review comment

[BMEN E3320] Fluid Biomechanics

Departments: Biology & Biomedical Engineering

Professors: Kevin Costa and Jeffrey Holmes

August 31, 2008

Costa, Kevin Silver_nugget
[BMEN E3320] Fluid Biomechanics

The Class: This fluid biomechanics class was probably as interesting as it could get given the subject manner. Lectures are presented with a qualitative analysis of what each organ/system does, followed by a mechanics based model that tried to mathematically simulate the body. The class gets long since it's 2 hours and 45 minutes long, but it's important to go to since the lectures are clear and the examples useful. The homeworks are usually difficult (although they can vary) but worth a hefty percentage of your grade (5 x 10% each). The midterms (3 x 10%) were on the easier side of fair (slightly) and drew extensively from the homework and example problems. The final was a longer and slightly easier version of the midterms, again on the easier side of fair (20%). Overall the class is pretty useful, as interesting as it can be, the workload is very fair, and the grading isn't too bad.

The Professor: Professor Costa was very friendly and approachable. It was very refreshing to have a professor who seemed to view teaching as enjoyable, instead of an irritating distraction from his/her research. Prof. Costa's lectures were well prepared, orderly, and clear. He is very fair to the students and always willing to help. In fact some of his best tips/explanations come during office hours. Unfortunately, Prof. Costa may not be returning this fall, which is certainly Columbia's loss. Although this is a research oriented university, Columbia could definitely use more instructors of Prof. Costa's caliber.

Workload:

Fair: 5 Problem sets (hard) (50%), 3 midterm quizzes (very fair) (30%), and a final (easier than midterms) (20%).

May 22, 2008

Costa, Kevin Silver_nugget
[BMEN E3320] Fluid Biomechanics

I don't think I've learned more in any class. Part of this is because of the volume of material that Fluid Biomechanics carries and part of it is because Costa really knows his stuff. There were sections (like Water and Solute Transport) that he was shaky on but included for the benefit of Cell & Tissue people, who could use that stuff. And although Professor Costa uses the outdated method of writing all his notes on the board for us to copy down, it proves to be beneficial, as the notes are something you'd want to keep for reference later on. All exams are open notes and open book and reflect what you saw in the homework.

Although Costa probably isn't teaching at Columbia next year, I believe he deserved a good review. I feel very fortunate to have taken his class while I had the opportunity to.

Workload:

A lot. Homeworks are a part-time job but each one is as much as an exam, so putting in the time is worth it, in the end. Costa's notorious for cheating -- don't even think about it. Besides, you'll be glad you put in the effort when exams come around.

August 06, 2007

Costa, Kevin Silver_nugget
[BMEN E3320] Fluid Biomechanics

I heard some unsettling things about Costa's Biomech class, but I actually ended up enjoying the course more than many of the other BME requirements. I had to choose between a Transport oriented class and Biomech, and from what I heard from the Chem Es, the decision took no time at all. The beauty of Costa's class is that he rewards hard work from the students. His homework assignments are by no means easy; I distinctly remember working in Mudd or a computer lounge till 4 AM in the morning. Our class did exceptionally well on the midterms and homeworks, and so Costa decided to give us a really easy final. Almost everything on it we have done before. Fluid Biomech is not easy, but Costa does his best to explain every concept.

May 22, 2005

Holmes, Jeffrey
[BMEN E3320] Fluid Biomechanics

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

Professor Holmes struck me as pretty bipolar on his perception of us as a class. While rumors circulated about how weak and stupid he thought we were, he smiled, held lecture, and even bought us pizza during finals.

The class, however and his expectations, are ridiculous. Besides going to class, he holds an unofficial discussion section which is more or less mandatory since test questions come out of it. Moreover, he will not discuss tests and HW during class, making his various office hours mandatory as well. On top of this, he has little to no curve, so every point you lose--is lost. He wears his MD/PHD like a sheriff badge, and thinks everyone whould have one.

A difficult class, with difficult hw and difficult tests. Good luck.

Workload:

5 psets. Each will take years.

September 22, 2003

Holmes, Jeffrey
[BMEN E3320] Fluid Biomechanics

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

This is probably the hardest class in the BME curriculum, but the one where you learn the most. Sherlock puts a lot of effort into the class, and expects an equal amount of effort in return. If he feels slighted he takes it out on your grades. The problem sets are all time intensive, but do-able if you put the work in. Everyone usually fails the first hw, but then the grades even out as people learn they have to work harder, or just get the answers from the TA's. So even though homeworks are 50% of the grade, they end up being a wash in terms of the curve. Just do them and do them well.

There are three quizes that are open notes. The quizzes test more for how you approach a problem instead of specific material based questions. There tends to be one or two easy material based questions, then two qualitative questions to set the curve. The easy questions come right out of the notes, and if you can read and write you should get them. the qualitative questions make you think and are his way of testing your problem solving methodology and seeing if you "think like an engineer." Some of the questions don't even have real answers, so don't feel confined by reality if he is asking for possible solutions to a biomedical related problem.

I found him approachable, even outside of office hours. He hated my class, due to some prolific cheaters(some eventually receiving national pub) and he only gave one A from what I heard. He liked the class before mine though, and gave 11 A's. So either your grade heavily relies on his perception of you and your class, or my class was full of retards(take your pick). He hates pre-meds and people who grub for grades, but is extremely helpful if you are actually interested in the material and work hard.

Workload:

5 homeworks for 50%. 3 quizzes for 30%. Final 20%

Directory Data

Dept/Subj Directory Course Professor Year Semester Time Section
BMEN / BMEN BMEN BMEN E3320: Fluid Biomechanics Hayden Huang 2012 Spring TR / 9:10-10:25 AM 1
BMEN / BMEN BMEN BMEN E3320: Fluid Biomechanics Hayden Huang 2011 Spring TR / 9:10-10:25 AM 1
BMEN / BMEN BMEN BMEN E3320: Fluid Biomechanics Hayden Huang 2010 Spring TR / 9:10-10:25 AM 1
BMEN / BMEN BMEN BMEN E3320: Fluid Biomechanics 2010 Spring F / 9:00-10:00 AM 0
BMEN / BMEN BMEN BMEN E3320: Fluid Biomechanics David Elad 2009 Spring TR / 9:10-10:25 AM 1
BMEN / BMEN BMEN BMEN E3320: Fluid Biomechanics Kevin Costa 2008 Spring T / 1:10- 3:55 PM 1
BMEN / BMEN BMEN BMEN E3320: Fluid Biomechanics Kevin Costa 2007 Spring TR / 9:10-10:25 AM 1
BMEN / BMEN BMEN BMEN E3320: Fluid Biomechanics Kevin Costa 2006 Spring TR / 9:10-10:25 AM 1
BMEN / BMEN BMEN BMEN E3320: Fluid Biomechanics Jeffrey Holmes 2005 Spring TR / 9:10-10:25 AM 1
BMEN / BMEN BMEN BMEN E3320: Fluid Biomechanics Jeffrey Holmes 2004 Spring TR / 9:10-10:25 AM 1
BMEN / BMEN BMEN BMEN E3320: Fluid Biomechanics Jeffrey Holmes 2003 Spring TR / 9:10-10:25 AM 1
BMEN / BMEN BMEN BMEN E3320: Fluid Biomechanics Jeffrey Holmes 2001 Spring TR / 9:10-10:25 AM 1