review comment

[BC3033] Intermediate Macroeconomic Theory

Departments: Economics

Professors: Andre Burgstaller, Mariana Colacelli, Sharon Harrison, and Helios Herrera

January 18, 2012

Herrera, Helios
[BC3033] Intermediate Macroeconomic Theory

He is too good looking to be allowed to teach at a women's college. I spent half the class paying attention and half checking him out. That aside, he is a great, energetic, charismatic professor who gets students engaged in the subject matter and goes at a reasonable pace. It is a workload but it is tolerable. Only complaint was accessibility outside the classroom. He seems to just wanna teach the class and go home and not make his office hours too plentiful. But if you pay attention and take notes, you won't really need the office hours.

Workload:

Substantial but fair and reasonable.

December 21, 2010

Colacelli, Mariana
[BC3033] Intermediate Macroeconomic Theory

I really enjoyed this class. the prof is extremely nice! her office hrs are never crowded so go with questions because she goes over all of your issues without making you feel stupid! she teaches right out of the text book but i would recommend going to class because she explains everything very well. the ta sessions are also very helpful if the ta is good (thankfully the first one sucked but left so we got a much better one midway through the semester). the problem sets are hard but if you can do them and understand how to do them you will do fine on the test. the avg of the midterm was 70% and it was curved very generously. i would def recommend this course with prof colacelli because she is so nice and does not try present info we have no idea how to answer on the exams (the questions are challenging though). overall i have nothing to complain about!

Workload:

weekly very hard problem sets, readings (optional but recommend them because they help with the homework), midterm, final

December 28, 2009

Burgstaller, Andre
[BC3033] Intermediate Macroeconomic Theory

He may be one of the NICEST people I have ever met. But, that does not change the fact that this class (and his individual lectures) is SO disorganized. We use a textbook, but he refutes it every chance he gets. There is a practice midterm which is pretty much identical to the actual midterm, but the wording is RIDICULOUS (so confusing), as is the subsequent curve (around 30-40 points for me). Plus, he goes off on tangents. As a result, we barely covered a small portion of the plan intended on the syllabus. I do not feel even remotely confident in my knowledge of economics, and I know that's a common sentiment in the class.

He is quite nice, though; I will give him that.

Workload:

A few problem sets at the beginning of the year that the TA doesn't even look at, midterm, "extra-credit" presentations in groups of 3 that just wasted everybody's time, final

Midterm worth 45%, final 45%, participation 10%

December 11, 2008

Colacelli, Mariana
[BC3033] Intermediate Macroeconomic Theory

Although a very nice woman, Prof. Colacelli should not be teaching a 3000 level "core" economics class. This was her first semester teaching non-intro, and it showed. She literally lectures directly out of the text, never explains examples and is unable to answer questions on the problem sets. Your best bet is to become best friends with the TA and hope she curves tremendously. The material is not hard in lecture, and you will walk out thinking how easy macro is, and then will be lost within 10 minutes on the problem set. Overall, it is better to suffer through a harder class than to take this one and learn absolutely nothing.

Workload:

typical. 10 problem sets, short relevant articles posted, midterm, final

May 07, 2006

Harrison, Sharon Silver_nugget
[BC3033] Intermediate Macroeconomic Theory

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

She basically goes along with the book. You can either go to class or read the book; you really don't need to do both. The weekly problem sets are very easy and pretty short. The test questions are taken directly from the homework. This class is incredibly easy, and she's a generous grader. The class is more of a basic, introductory class for students to "understand the world better" and "understand the news" (she starts each class with asking students what they've read in the Times recently and relating the events to Macroeconomics...which, don't get me wrong, is pretty cool). All-in-all Professor Harrison is a pretty nice, cool, easy professor to have for a required theory class. But the class doesn't cover a fraction of what the Macro class equivalent across the street does, and it shies away from any difficult math. All you need to know is how to move the lines around in a graph, which is pretty intuitive (Mankiw-like) stuff anyway.

Workload:

Very light: an easy problem set ever week, very straightforward midterm and final.

December 29, 2004

Harrison, Sharon Silver_nugget
[BC3033] Intermediate Macroeconomic Theory

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

Professor Harrison is awesome! She really cares about her students and wants them to do well. She teaches at a steady pace and tries not to speed right through the material. She patiently answers questions and never makes a student feel stupid for asking. Everything is very clear because it is written on the blackboard. If a concept is confusing, she rewords it in different ways so that it is more clear. She is definitely passionate about the subject and makes Economics less intimidating.

Workload:

Weekly problem sets (helps in learning the material and guides you in what you actually need to read in the textbook), one midterm, one final

December 26, 2004

Harrison, Sharon Silver_nugget
[BC3033] Intermediate Macroeconomic Theory

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

The first day of Harrison's class, the minute she opened her mouth, I knew that I'd found my major advisor. SH is the kindest, funniest, most down-to-earth professor I've ever had. And I wasn't alone in falling for her -- the entire class enjoyed our time with her, and at the end of the last lecture of the semester, we spontaneously applauded. Harrison made economics fun, and she really wanted us to enjoy the subject as much as she does.

Workload:

A problem set due each week; can be time-consuming. The midterm and final are straight-forward, thankfully!

Directory Data

Dept/Subj Directory Course Professor Year Semester Time Section
ECOB / ECON ECOB ECON BC3033: Intermedte Macroeconomc Theory Maria Garibotti 2012 Spring MW / 9:10-10:25 AM 1
ECOB / ECON ECOB ECON BC3033: Intermedte Macroeconomc Theory Andre Burgstaller 2012 Fall TR / 6:10- 7:25 PM 1
ECOB / ECON ECOB ECON BC3033: Intermedte Macroeconomc Theory Andre Burgstaller 2011 Spring TR / 1:10- 2:25 PM 1
ECOB / ECON ECOB ECON BC3033: Intermedte Macroeconomc Theory Marcellus Andrews 2010 Spring TR / 2:40- 3:55 PM 1
ECOB / ECON ECOB ECON BC3033: Intermedte Macroeconomc Theory Mariana Colacelli 2010 Fall TR / 9:10-10:25 AM 1
ECOB / ECON ECOB ECON BC3033: Intermedte Macroeconomc Theory Mariana Colacelli 2009 Spring MW / 10:35-11:50 AM 1
ECOB / ECON ECOB ECON BC3033: Intermedte Macroeconomc Theory Andre Burgstaller 2009 Fall TR / 5:40- 6:55 PM 1
ECOB / ECON ECOB ECON BC3033: Intermedte Macroeconomc Theory Mariana Colacelli 2008 Fall MW / 10:35-11:50 AM 1
ECOB / ECON ECOB ECON BC3033: Intermedte Macroeconomc Theory Marcellus Andrews 2008 Spring TR / 10:35-11:50 AM 1
ECOB / ECON ECOB ECON BC3033: Intermedte Macroeconomc Theory Nidhi Thakur 2007 Fall MW / 2:40- 3:55 PM 1
ECOB / ECON ECOB ECON BC3033: Intermedte Macroeconomc Theory Sharon Harrison 2006 Fall MW / 10:35-11:50 AM 1
ECOB / ECON ECOB ECON BC3033: Intermedte Macroeconomc Theory Sharon Harrison 2005 Fall TR / 2:40- 3:55 PM 1
ECOB / ECON ECOB ECON BC3033: Intermedte Macroeconomc Theory Perry Mehrling 2005 Spring MW / 4:10- 5:25 PM 1
ECOB / ECON ECOB ECON BC3033: Intermedte Macroeconomc Theory Sharon Harrison 2004 Fall TR / 2:40- 3:55 PM 1
ECOB / ECON ECOB ECON BC3033: Intermedte Macroeconomc Theory Steven Malin 2004 Spring W / 6:10- 8:40 PM 1
ECOB / ECON ECOB ECON BC3033: Intermedte Macroeconomc Theory Rajiv Sethi 2003 Fall MW / 1:10- 2:25 PM 1
ECOB / ECON ECOB ECON BC3033: Intermedte Macroeconomc Theory Carl Wennerlind 2003 Spring TR / 10:35-11:50 AM 1
ECOB / ECON ECOB ECON BC3033: Intermedte Macroeconomc Theory Carl Wennerlind 2002 Fall TR / 10:35-11:50 AM 1
ECOB / ECON ECOB ECON BC3033: Intermedte Macroeconomc Theory Rajiv Sethi 2001 Spring MW / 1:10- 2:25 PM 1