review comment

Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish

Departments: Spanish and Portuguese

Professors: Gina Diaz, Cherrymae Golston, Perla Rozencvaig, and Carlos Sanchez

Perla is absolutely fantastic. If you are looking to take Spanish with someone who not only really cares about her students, but is also an expert in her field, you'll be in luck with Perla. It is so obvious that she loves teaching, and she makes an effort to make sure that all of her students stay on track with the course. If you need extra help, she's extremely accommodating. She's also super understanding if you need an extension. She grades fairly in my opinion. Participation is a large part of your grade, and she calls on people so essentially everyone participates which helps when final grades come out. If you get a chance to talk with her about Cuban politics or any politics really, definitely do so! She's a wealth of knowledge. If you're enthusiastic and put effort into the class, she won't over look it.

Pretty much, she's great. I definitely recommend any of her classes. (I've taken three with her.)

Workload:

Compositions: 3 or 4 and fairly graded; also she'll help you if you go to her
Readings: Most are interesting; in her advanced class, they can get really hard so give yourself time to complete them
Homework: Part of the grade, but never actually checked and easy to provide answers on the spot
Participation: It's a language class. If you have a problems with speaking in class, you should probably get over that.
Enthusiasm: Can't hurt

December 14, 2010

Rozencvaig, Perla Silver_nugget
Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish

Perla's certainly very nice, but I must say this class turned me off to Spanish and Hispanic studies greatly. Classes were repetitive, which is typical with languages, but she rarely clearly explained the grammar we were studying. Had I not known most of the grammar beforehand I probably would have gone crazy. She definitely had favorites and didn't try to hide that, calling on the same few people over and over again. Her policy on compositions (she averages the grade between original and revised versions) was unnecessary since she rarely bumped the grade any more than from a B to a B+ even if all corrections were made. I also found it frustrating that she never responded to emails or made an effort to use Courseworks (or any technology) in this class.

Overall, she's a sweet woman but did not create an environment or class that I enjoyed or found to inspire interest in the language.

p.s. Don't get all of the books listed on courseworks (and DON'T buy the $80 online component), because we never used an expensive textbook or the online version. $115 wasted, $80 of which I can't get back.

Workload:

Lots of exercises in the books, but she never checks them so if you're quick on your feet you can still participate in class without doing the homework. Three compositions and revisions, three movies to watch outside of class, group project, midterm (which was super easy), oral final and in-class final.

January 02, 2010

Rozencvaig, Perla Silver_nugget
Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish

I took Perla's Comprehensive Spanish class, which is a combination of Intermediate 1&2. It was the fastest and easiest way to get through the language requirement and it was so enjoyable. Perla is such a sweet woman and her class was my most enjoyable class during my first semester here at Columbia. The class is not that difficult. She calls on students alot in order to get everyone to participate (class was only 17 students). So, I recommend that you do the homework so that when she randomly calls on you, you can actually answer the question correctly instead of worrying because you're not prepared. The movies that she assigned for us to watch were really good. We discussed them in class, some much more than others. As long as you sometimes have one thing to say, your good. There were days when I would barely say one thing in class, but I guess I proved myself in other ways because I surprisingly got an A-. The final group project counted for a good amount. It was written and oral. I think it definitely helps your grade if you put the effort in. I definitely would recommend Perla because she's so amazing and reminded me of caring high-school teachers, which I don't think I'll find often around here.

cons: A little disorganized, especially when it comes to what she assigned for homework and from what books. A little confusion on the final project in terms what she expected for the first draft, but it didn't affect anyone's grades. We almost had an in class essay, which would have been kind of hard, but luckily, we ran out of time in class and we never had to do it. She taught alot of material in the last handful of classes, including several new verb tenses. Most of the multiple choice on the final was about verb tenses.

Workload:

Daily homework from 1-3 books(textbook and workbooks), 4 movies to watch out of class (all of which had english subtitles), 2 pg responses to these films(we get to rewrite EVERYTHING so it's great!), 2 short stories to read, Final group project, midterm(good) and final(fair)

December 28, 2006

Sanchez, Carlos
Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

If you get Carlos, count yourself lucky. Not only is he funny, easy going and an adept teacher moreover, he likes his students and understands we work hard. That's the pc way of saying he doesn't kill you with busy work. Great class to actually practice speaking. He won't make fun of miserable accents or look down at you as you fumble the conjugations outloud for the first time. If your first year left you feeling like a spanish retard, this is a great class to review the grammar and get comfortable using it. I highly recommend him.

Workload:

It really depends on how well you learned grammar. The class itself is just review. If you learned well, it is easy. If not, you will have to discipline yourself to study hard because the class goes through a chapter a week. Not a lot of homework but if you didn't study, it'll catch up with you on the tests.

January 17, 2006

Golston, Cherrymae
Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

Prof. Golston does like participation, but she encourages some fun and thoughtful participation from her students, who often get excited during the discussions. She genuinely wants her students to be as excited as she is and to really learn the language. She speaks very clearly and fluently though she is not a native speaker. What stands out most is that she is a caring individual that wants to hear your voice--we will often stray from the informal course plan to talk about something she believes is more important. She will talk occasionally about her family and personal life...so maybe you will be lucky enough to have her husband as professor as well (he is a gold nugget, by the way)!

Workload:

Yes, there is some busy work, but that is all expected when learning a language. A few compositions that she has you correct, tests (she drops the lowest score), and the occasional dialouge or group story/presentation. Definatley manageable.

August 31, 2004

Diaz, Gina
Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

Everything the other two reviewers said about the Spring 2004 course is completely right. Although she is a very sweet person, she shouldn't be teaching Spanish, as even she will admit she doesn't know how to teach grammar. There is nothing you can learn from her that you can't learn from the book [faster and less painfully].

May 20, 2004

Diaz, Gina
Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

gina is a very nice person, who i think honestly believes that she is teaching you. unfortunately, she isn't. the class is conducted at least 50% in english (sounds nice until you realize you aren't really learning spanish). nonetheless, when you ask her to explain a grammar point, she can't explain it, saying that instead you should instinctively know it.....from hearing the spanish that she never forces you to speak! my class was also bogged down by people who were all to eager to speak english and carry on fairly pointless conversations, whom gina allowed largely to run the class. to be fair, it isn't entirely her fault.

Workload:

like any language class, loads of busy work. while she is a very nice person, that niceness does not translate into what i would call easy grading.

May 05, 2004

Diaz, Gina
Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

This class was the bane of my existence for the entire spring semester. Gina is a very nice person, which is why I feel bad giving her such a bad review. Her class is completely unstructured. It was not made clear what we had to learn or why we had to learn it. Quizzes would be given with ambigous answers. She did not encourage classroom conversation. The whole class was a big waste of time as I did not need it for the language requirement.

Workload:

quizzes/workbooks/studying that will get you nowhere...

Directory Data

Dept/Subj Directory Course Professor Year Semester Time Section
SPPO / SPAN SPPO SPAN W1220: Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish Ruth Borgman 2012 Spring MWF / 1:10- 2:25 PM 1
SPPO / SPAN SPPO SPAN W1220: Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish Ruth Borgman 2012 Spring MWF / 2:40- 3:55 PM 2
SPPO / SPAN SPPO SPAN W1220: Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish Perla Rozencvaig 2012 Fall TRF / 2:40- 3:55 PM 1
SPPO / SPAN SPPO SPAN W1220: Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish Perla Rozencvaig 2012 Fall TRF / 4:10- 5:25 PM 2
SPPO / SPAN SPPO SPAN W1220: Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish Ruth Borgman 2010 Spring TRF / 4:10- 5:25 PM 1
SPPO / SPAN SPPO SPAN W1220: Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish Ruth Borgman 2010 Spring TRF / 6:10- 7:25 PM 2
SPPO / SPAN SPPO SPAN W1220: Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish Perla Rozencvaig 2010 Fall TRF / 1:10- 2:25 PM 1
SPPO / SPAN SPPO SPAN W1220: Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish Perla Rozencvaig 2010 Fall TRF / 2:40- 3:55 PM 2
SPPO / SPAN SPPO SPAN W1220: Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish Raquel Diez-Diaz 2009 Spring F / 4:10- 5:25 PM 1
SPPO / SPAN SPPO SPAN W1220: Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish Raquel Diez-Diaz 2009 Spring R / 6:10- 7:25 PM 2
SPPO / SPAN SPPO SPAN W1220: Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish Perla Rozencvaig 2009 Fall TRF / 2:40- 3:55 PM 1
SPPO / SPAN SPPO SPAN W1220: Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish Perla Rozencvaig 2009 Fall TRF / 4:10- 5:25 PM 2
SPPO / SPAN SPPO SPAN W1220: Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish Ruth Borgman 2008 Fall W / 10:35-11:50 AM 1
SPPO / SPAN SPPO SPAN W1220: Comprehensive Intermediate Spanish Ruth Borgman 2008 Fall MWR / 1:10- 2:25 PM 2