review comment

CHNS G4015-G4016 Readings in Modern Chinese

Departments: East-Asian Languages and Cultures

Professors: Yuan-Yuan Meng

January 22, 2011

Meng, Yuan-Yuan Silver_nugget
CHNS G4015-G4016 Readings in Modern Chinese

Professor Meng is one of the most quirkiest and well organized teachers I've met in Columbia. Also, she truly cares about her students. She is concerned about their well being and makes an effort to truly get to know and empathize with each. Her readings are challenging but nothing impossible. Her clear sense of direction coupled with her meticulous word sheets provides enough guidance in and of themselves, but her clear instruction leaves room for no nonsense. Also, the readings expose you to parts of Chinese culture you would never have encountered from real authors and real political texts (instead of edited textbook material) If you take this class, you'll learn a lot. Just do your work and speak out.

Workload:

Four to five tests spread out, one of which you can drop as well as regular tingxie and three to five essays, few short homework assignments.

September 10, 2009

Meng, Yuan-Yuan Silver_nugget
CHNS G4015-G4016 Readings in Modern Chinese

I have had Meng for two years running now, and while I've had a lot of outstanding teachers at Columbia, she outstrips them all. Leaving aside, for the time being, the ferocious devotion she inspires in her students (we loved her so much we asked her to help us create a new 5th year-level class, Media Chinese, so that we might not have to be parted from her), she simply works harder for you than any other professor I've encountered here. It doesn't hurt that she can be hilarious in class, either--though she will bust your ass if you don't do the work. She is immune to BS--you simply cannot get it by her, and if you try, she will smack you down in front of the whole class.

It is worth noting, I suppose, her inclination towards non-native speakers. She does not teach W-level Chinese, and while she does not bar native speakers, they sometimes have trouble in her class, largely because of her outspoken contempt for the PRC government. Nor is she a big fan of the ROC either, though--she is very political, but even here, she has one extremely rare quality--she is absolutely receptive to argument. Not even in that aggravating "you have the right to your wrong opinion" sort of way, that speaks in tones of contempt and disdain. She actually listens, and trusts in the intellect of her students. We argued with her all semester, and never once complained that she was unfair, condescending, or superior, as professors so often are. Instead, arguments were absolutely stimulating, fascinating, and passionate.

Basically, if you want to learn real Chinese you study with Meng.

Workload:

One of the things that is most prodigious about her is that while the workload is heavy, it is never just busywork. Everything she makes you do is emphatically useful and constructive. You will not be doing rote exercises--even her rewrites of essays are useful.

Quizzes every class, 4-5 tests, one sometimes dropped, occasional essays with handwritten rewrite, and a hefty but doable reading load. Oral midterm and final. The final is so miraculously designed that you will actually feel like you're learning as you do it, and you'll be done in about an hour and a half.

December 31, 1999

Meng, Yuan-Yuan Silver_nugget
CHNS G4015-G4016 Readings in Modern Chinese

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

I took this class as an undergraduate. At the beginning of the year, I had to pick between Sobelman and Meng's sections, and I picked Meng's because it looked a lot more structured and also because I would learn a lot more in Meng's class. Meng laoshi's class is very intense, and you'll definitely need to devote the time to memorize characters for tingshie and for homework. I recommend the class if you've got the time and energy. The tests are killers.

December 31, 1999

Meng, Yuan-Yuan Silver_nugget
CHNS G4015-G4016 Readings in Modern Chinese

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

This class is pretty notorious but notorious for the wrong reasons. Meng laoshi is from Taiwan, and you can really tell this by her bias. It's definitely a ton of work and in my opinion, a lot of it is useless work. So much of the vocabulary we learn is impractical. Also expect to devote a disproportianate amount of time on news articles. If you're into anything else, this class isn't for you. Although, I hear Sobelman's class is even lousier. You should just go on ahead to 5th year Chinese with Liu laoshi (awesome guy) and skip 4th year-you'll save yourself a lot of headaches.

Directory Data

Dept/Subj Directory Course Professor Year Semester Time Section
EALC / CHNS EALC CHNS G4016: Readings in Modern Chinese Yuan-Yuan Meng 2012 Spring MTWR / 10:00-10:50 AM 1
EALC / CHNS EALC CHNS G4016: Readings in Modern Chinese Ling Yan 2012 Spring MTR / 5:40- 6:55 PM 2
EALC / CHNS EALC CHNS G4016: Readings in Modern Chinese Yuan-Yuan Meng 2011 Spring MTWR / 10:00-10:50 AM 1
EALC / CHNS EALC CHNS G4016: Readings in Modern Chinese Ling Yan 2011 Spring MWR / 5:40- 6:55 PM 2
EALC / CHNS EALC CHNS G4016: Readings in Modern Chinese Yuan-Yuan Meng 2010 Spring MTWR / 10:00-10:50 AM 1
EALC / CHNS EALC CHNS G4016: Readings in Modern Chinese Ling Yan 2010 Spring MWR / 5:40- 6:55 PM 2
EALC / CHNS EALC CHNS G4016: Readings in Modern Chinese Yuan-Yuan Meng 2009 Spring MTWR / 10:00-10:50 AM 1
EALC / CHNS EALC CHNS G4016: Readings in Modern Chinese Ling Yan 2009 Spring MWR / 5:40- 6:55 PM 2
EALC / CHNS EALC CHNS G4016: Readings in Modern Chinese Yuann-Yuann Meng 2006 Spring MTR / 11:00-12:10 PM 1
EALC / CHNS EALC CHNS G4016: Readings in Modern Chinese Yuann-Yuann Meng 2005 Spring MTR / 4:10- 5:20 PM 1
EALC / CHNS EALC CHNS G4016: Readings in Modern Chinese 2004 Spring MTR / 4:10- 5:20 PM 1
EALC / CHNS EALC CHNS G4016: Readings in Modern Chinese Yuann-Yuann Meng 2003 Spring MTR / 4:10- 5:20 PM 1
EALC / CHNS EALC CHNS G4016: Readings in Modern Chinese 2002 Spring MWR / 1:10- 2:20 PM 1