review comment

[POLS BC3082] American Women in the 20th Century

Departments: Political Science

Professors: Rosalind Rosenberg

January 29, 2009

Rosenberg, Rosalind Silver_nugget
[POLS BC3082] American Women in the 20th Century

I realize that Professor Rosenberg is not really in need of another wonderful review, but, honestly, she deserves it. This class was easily one of the best that I have taken in my life. Let's start with the subject matter...

You may think that you understand American History and the role that women have played in it, but, if you take this class, you will quickly realize how much there is to learn. The information taught is not only interesting - it is relevant. You will learn things that apply to your every day life, you will be outraged at comments made and laws passed (some of which remain unresolved), you will learn about the history of Barnard and of Columbia, and, perhaps most importantly, you will learn to think (and write) like a true student of history.

This is not to say, however, that the class is perfect. There is a lot of reading and, though most of it is interesting, lectures are not based on the reading and it is never discussed. Professor Rosenberg does not forbid discussion, but her lectures are clearly well planned and she does not really welcome it. That is not to say that you can't ask questions, though! And discussions do happen, just perhaps not as often as would be ideal.

Okay, now on to what makes this class exceptional, rather than just great...Professor Rosenberg is truly an inspiration. She is brimming with knowledge, clear and well spoken, kind, and personable. She is very flexible and will meet you if you can't make her office hours and I never had to wait longer than a few hours for a response to an email. She understands the needs of students and the demands that are placed upon them, often encouraging you to relax if you seem to be too stressed. I know that some did not find her as approachable as others, perhaps because she is not an easy teacher. This class is not about getting an easy A, though an A is certainly an achievable grade, but about learning. She will push you, in your final paper, to form a sophisticated argument. If you are dedicated and interested, you will reap the benefits of a teacher whom I believe to be one of the gems of Barnard.

Workload:

Reading varies from week to week, but I would not call this a class with light reading. Not as excessive as some (and most of it is very interesting!), but it's not a breeze, either. There are three graded papers for this class, though each paper also requires a first draft which is not graded but given to the writing fellows. The papers build on each other, and, thus, you really only write on one topic the whole semester. Meeting with a writing fellow about each paper is a required component of the class and, though you may not get much out of these meetings, they are painless. Also, each revision does allow you to build on your argument and meet with Professor Rosenberg if things don't make sense. There is also a final, which is pretty difficult. But, once again, go to class, work hard, do the reading, and you'll be fine.

January 02, 2009

Rosenberg, Rosalind Silver_nugget
[POLS BC3082] American Women in the 20th Century

Fantastic class! Professor Rosenberg is not only overflowing with knowledge about modern U.S. women's history, but is also adept at presenting the information in an engaging and thoughtful manner. Lectures are packed with information that I think most students in the class would find relevant and interesting, like the evolution of women's education at Barnard. Take anything you can with this professor!

Workload:

3 papers that gradually increase in length, final

January 15, 2002

Rosenberg, Rosalind Silver_nugget
[POLS BC3082] American Women in the 20th Century

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

Workload:

One 1 pg document analysis, one 3-5 pg. paper expanding on the document, a 5-7 pg. paper. No midterm, one final. Length of readings varies from week to week. After a certain point, you realize which readings are important and which ones you can sort of skim. Grading depends on your TA.

December 16, 2001

Rosenberg, Rosalind Silver_nugget
[POLS BC3082] American Women in the 20th Century

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

Professor Rosenberg is an extremely intelligent and compassionate person. Her brain is overflowing with knowledge, and some of it starts to spill out in the form of her talking on and on in class. Lectures are interesting, as long as you have had your coffee -- she has a very motherly sounding voice that can lull you into a doze if you aren't careful. The material ranges from fascinating to boring, and Rosenberg is very careful about being objective in this class -- you'll read about all different perspectives of feminism and you're not expected to write "womyn" in your papers. In other words, you don't have to be a member of NOW in order to enjoy this class ... although after taking it, you might decide to join.

Workload:

A one-page document analysis and two 4-6 page research papers. Very managable. There is a lot of reading, which is hunky-dory when the material is interesting, but sometimes it's a bit of a drag.

December 31, 1999

Rosenberg, Rosalind Silver_nugget
[POLS BC3082] American Women in the 20th Century

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

This course covered Immigrants, Suffragettes, the Roaring 20's, WWII and the women at home, women's lib, NOW, and the anti-feminist backlash. Rosenberg is kind and intellegent and very approachable. She always incorporated all types of media - the web, videos, photos etc. There were also some trips to museums, for example, the tenement museum on the lower east side. The course is discussion format, and as such it is really hard to get into. You have to apply early. But it is worth it - Rosenberg gives you the other half of history, and you'll come back for more.

Workload:

Very fair, about one book a week, but she was also really nice about extensions and things like that if the class expressed exasperation. Midterm was paper or test. Final paper and Final exam. Papers were about 7-10 pages.

Directory Data

Dept/Subj Directory Course Professor Year Semester Time Section