review comment

[CLEA W4101] Literary and Cultural Theory: East and West

Departments: East-Asian Languages and Cultures and English and Comparative Literature

Professors: Lydia Liu and Haruo Shirane

December 12, 2009

Liu, Lydia
[CLEA W4101] Literary and Cultural Theory: East and West

This was the most challenging, engaging, and rewarding class that I've taken at Columbia. This class introduces a vast array of literary and cultural theory, which is crucial for EALAC majors concentrating on literature and Comp Lit majors. Professor Liu is incredible knowledgeable, and she knows how to balance giving us background information without compromising the class discussions. I don't know if there's anyone more knowledgeable here about the issue of the East meeting the West in terms of translation, literature, and cultural exchange. She is good at raising challenging questions and prompting us to engage with the texts. Her class will definitely improve your critical thinking skills. I recommend this class for those up for a challenging and exciting class.

Workload:

A lot of work, but worth it! Weekly readings (150-250 pages), weekly online discussion response, 1 presentation, 2 papers.

December 31, 1999

Shirane, Haruo
[CLEA W4101] Literary and Cultural Theory: East and West

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

The syllabus is overly comprehensive, allowing only a day of discussion for difficult topics such as deconstructionism, freudian theory, post-colonialism, etc. The readings for each topic are not necessarily the most relevant, but always very difficult, requiring at least 3 hours of prep for each session. Prof. Shirane not only takes attendance every class like an elementary school teacher, he calls on students at random, so the reading is necessary. Unfortunately, his lectures and questions are nothing more than a synopsis of the reading, neither offering nor stimulating independent thought. And beware: if you reverse the situation and ask him a question he gets flustered and brushes the question off for later. Class discussion, the one glimmer of hope that sparks up every once in awhile, is quickly squelched since he's too busy rushing through his summaries.

Directory Data

Dept/Subj Directory Course Professor Year Semester Time Section
EALC / CLEA EALC CLEA W4101: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West Paul Anderer 2012 Spring W / 2:10- 4:00 PM 1
EALC / CLEA EALC CLEA W4101: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West Paul Anderer 2011 Spring T / 2:10- 4:00 PM 1
EALC / CLEA EALC CLEA W4101: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West Lydia Liu 2010 Spring R / 2:10- 4:00 PM 1
EALC / CLEA EALC CLEA W4101: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West Lydia Liu 2009 Spring T / 2:10- 4:00 PM 1
EALC / CLEA EALC CLEA W4101: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West Theodore Hughes, Matthew Kutolowski 2008 Spring M / 2:10- 4:00 PM 1
EALC / CLEA EALC CLEA W4101: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West Lydia Liu 2007 Spring R / 4:10- 6:00 PM 1
EALC / CLEA EALC CLEA W4101: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West Theodore Hughes 2006 Spring W / 2:10- 4:00 PM 1
EALC / CLEA EALC CLEA W4101: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West Wendy Swartz 2005 Spring M / 2:10- 4:00 PM 1
EALC / CLEA EALC CLEA W4101: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West Haruo Shirane 2004 Spring MW / 1:10- 2:25 PM 1
EALC / CLEA EALC CLEA W4101: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West Haruo Shirane 2003 Spring MW / 1:10- 2:25 PM 1
EALC / CLEA EALC CLEA W4101: Literature & Cultural Thry East/West David Wang 2002 Spring TR / 1:10- 2:25 PM 1
EALC / CLEA EALC CLEA W4101: Literature & Cultural Thry: East/West: Literature & Cultural Thry East/West David Wang 2002 Spring TR / 1:10- 2:25 PM 1
EALC / CLEA EALC CLEA W4101: Literature & Cultural Thry East/West Haruo Shirane 2001 Spring MW / 1:10- 2:25 PM 1