review comment

[HIST BC3321] Colonial Encounters

Departments: History

Professors: Lisa Tiersten

January 18, 2011

Tiersten, Lisa Silver_nugget
[HIST BC3321] Colonial Encounters

I thought Tiersten was absolutely amazing and her course was fascinating. Initially, I was nervous about taking this course as the course did not seem interesting. The course was so interesting and Tiersten blew me away with her great wealth of knowledge. I would recommend this class to anyone who enjoys history. It is a must-take course!!!! I walked away from each class feeling accomplished and so much more knowledgable. She speaks rapid-fire style but you'll learn to keep up immediately. The course is also not extremely demanding. You can essentially pick and choose which readings you think are valuable. The midterm and the final are spelled out for you on an outline, so if you study hard--you will be rewarded.

Workload:

heavy readings but some are more essential than others. movie nights which were somewhat interesting. one paper(5-7) on any relevant topic. one final.

December 21, 2010

Tiersten, Lisa Silver_nugget
[HIST BC3321] Colonial Encounters

Lisa Tiersten is AWESOME. She is so interested with what she's talking about. And she really wants us to be interested, too. She speaks really animatedly and wildly which is kind of funny. She also tends to speak too quickly, which can be a little bit hard to keep up with when taking notes, but overall I absolutely LOVED this class. I actually LEARNED. She's also incredibly friendly and goes out of her way to help and get to know her students. I highly recommend this class if you're not good at history- this class will keep you interested with a relatively light workload to match.

Workload:

Absolutely manageable! Interesting readings and movies. One short paper (7 pages), 1 midterm- you get the question and essay options in advance so you can really prepare, 1 final, same style as midterm.

November 21, 2010

Tiersten, Lisa Silver_nugget
[HIST BC3321] Colonial Encounters

Looking at Professor Tiersten's glowing reviews, I was eager to take this class as a junior history major. While obviously a talented historian and an enthusiastic, if wildly disorganized lecturer, Tiersten is all over the place with this course. The vague subtitle of the course--European Culture in the Age of Empire--is telling: with such a broad time period to cover, Tiersten is unable to focus on either domestic events or their consequences for empire. Lectures are scattered, class discussion painfully reductive, and Tiersten's sweet-but-scatty appeal is undercut by her habit of brusquely interrupting students in order to tell would-be amusing anecdotes. Her classroom manner could use a dose of Professor Snape--she seems unable to exert authority, and lectures are ruined by her stream-of-consciousness remarks on her coffee, her missing glasses, and the attractiveness of the male actors in the clips she shows.
The course jumped from region to region without even attempting to make parallels or comment on trends in colonial policy, which was my biggest problem with it. This is a sorry excuse for a history class at best.

Workload:

Ridiculously easy. About one-fourth the amount of reading for an average 3000-level history course. Could've used a lot more secondary sources; as it was, we barely covered the topics presented. Midterm, short paper, final.

January 11, 2010

Tiersten, Lisa Silver_nugget
[HIST BC3321] Colonial Encounters

Professor Tiersten drinks an entertaining amount of coffee during class. She also talks REALLY quickly, which often makes it difficult to understand what she is saying, but she is really nice and would definitely meet with you outside of class if you had any questions. Her papers/exams are pretty straightforward and as long as you follow directions, it's pretty easy to get an A in the class. The readings for class are often long and sometimes quite boring, but if you do at least some of them, you are totally fine for the exams, so that shouldn't discourage you from taking the class. Generally, the class was pretty interesting and Professor Tiersten is really nice and pretty understanding about things, so it's worth it to take the class!

Workload:

1 short paper (7-10 pages), 1 midterm exam (IDs and Essays- handed out before-hand), 1 Final exam (same setup as midterm)

Professor Tiersten is, hands down, the best history professor offered at Columbia. She is so knowledgeable; the information she is able to convey coherently in a lecture setting is astounding. More importantly, she doesn't assign impossible amounts of work. For either lectures or seminars, her paper assignments are focused on quality, not quantity. Lectures require a crisp 5-7 page paper, and seminars a 15 page paper, both of which are very manageable. As for her reading assignments, I admit that she does demand a large amount of reading, and expect for it to be done. However, the reading material is always carefully selected and interesting. Perhaps the best aspect of her reading lists is that she rarely requires the reading of a whole book, but rather selects choice chapters which highlight the author's key points and argument. Professor Tiersten wants you to enjoy and learn from her classes, which is one of best traits. A true gold nugget!

Workload:

Manageable. Provides study guides for finals and midterms (come on- this alone should persuade you to take a class with her!), short and crisp paper assignments. Reading can be high volume, but it is interesting and worth it.

December 19, 2007

Tiersten, Lisa Silver_nugget
[HIST BC3321] Colonial Encounters

This is by far one of the best History classes I've taken at Columbia so far. Professor Tiersten is a very organised lecturer and provides handouts which she adheres to very well. Also, it helps that the reading material and films we saw were very interesting. The subject matter was very enticing as well. We dealt with stuff like Orientalism, modern day tourism, British Imperialism etc. It's one of those courses which makes you get a better sense of the world we live in today and its cultural tensions. Professor Tiersten is also very receptive in class towards comments (even though sometimes she should have shut off some dumb-ass columbia boys).

Grading is fair. She gives out study guides before the midterms and finals, so it makes studying a lot easier.

Workload:

light. 1- 2 readings a week. 1 essay. 1 mid term. 1 final. I felt this class was a lot lighter than other classes

April 07, 2007

Tiersten, Lisa Silver_nugget
[HIST BC3321] Colonial Encounters

If this class were a PBS program, I would've enjoyed it--there was a lot of information presented in fairly neat schemes. However, having to remember that information and put aside doubts about her generalizations into the previously-mentioned schemes makes the class a bit annoying. I think this is due to the awfully large span of the course (over 500 years!) and not the professor. She herself seems very friendly and the lectures were interesting (again, if I was just listening for fun and not feverishly taking notes, I would've enjoyed the class more). Everything was graded fairly and on time.

Workload:

Midterm, paper, final. Interesting readings that you need to be familiar with for exams (but they're often discussed in class, so I'm sure one could get by without doing them).

January 08, 2007

Tiersten, Lisa Silver_nugget
[HIST BC3321] Colonial Encounters

Professor Tiersten is one of the most intimidatingly intelligent teachers I've had yet at Columbia, and her rapid-fire lectures can be overwhelming. This class, about the effects of colonialism on imperial nations, was a fascinating study of how perceptions of the primitive changed through the centuries. Since it's so broad--500 years and an entire globe--she focuses more on the anthropological theories than the actual dates and names, which is fine if you're a theory person. Right after the semester ended, I took a vacation in Costa Rica, and found myself talking about it more than any other class. Pay attention and take good notes and you should do well and get a lot out of this one.

Workload:

Big coursepack (bits of which are more useful than others--skip the really dense jargon-heavy stuff) and weekly handouts, 8-10 page paper, in class midterm and final.

December 17, 2005

Tiersten, Lisa Silver_nugget
[HIST BC3321] Colonial Encounters

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

Tiersten is definitely a funny individual. One thing you should know about this class is that it is not a survey of what happened in colonialism, it is about how colonialism affected European culture. Besides that, Tiersten definitely keeps lectures entertaining. Sure, she interupts herself, and talks about how she might act crazy, but she always has a definite point, and you will learn from this class if you just pay attention. Also, it's really, really, easy. One paper, and an easy final and midterm. No worries.

Workload:

one 5-7 page paper, reading you don't have to do, and a final and midterm.

December 17, 2005

Tiersten, Lisa Silver_nugget
[HIST BC3321] Colonial Encounters

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

I highly recommend this class for anyone who has any interest in history whatsoever- or even if you're interested in the current events today relating to colonialism because Prof. Tiersten makes this class so interesting. She covers a lot of material (and talks REALLY fast so be prepared!!!) but it's all extremely interesting and you'll be glad you showed up to class. The paper assignment is a fun way to go into more detail of one of the topics you may have wanted to learn more about. Overall, great class even if you're not a history major like me.
Also- the movie assignments were really worthwhile- you get to see some great movies including Chocolat (not the one with Johnny Depp!), Cannibal Tours, Tarzan, etc.

Workload:

Pretty decent- reading isn't too bad, a couple movies to see, a midterm and a final (she gives you review sheets for both and she wants you to do well)

January 17, 2005

Tiersten, Lisa Silver_nugget
[HIST BC3321] Colonial Encounters

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

A lot of people trash talk Prof. Tiersten for her broad lectures or, well, fairly easy classes, but frankly there aren't enough teachers at CU and BC who give solid, survey introductions to non-Western history. Colonial Encounters is all over the place, and spans centuries; the course reading and lectures lay out a thematic overview of material you simply can't cover in detail in one course. So: Don't take it if you're looking to learn everything about one area or period. Take it if you want a smart, funny, well-informed lecturer who tells interesting stories and can help you connect what you already know to some broad, historical patterns. Tiersten is a fantastic speaker, a truly dedicated teacher, and nice to boot; her class is one that first-year history students should kick down the door to take. Also, ask her about the death of Captain Cook.

Workload:

Really, really easy. 5-7 pg paper, midterm+final (id's, essay); she always gives you a list of the id's beforehand, and she's a VERY generous grader. She's not anal about lecture attendence, but you should show up anyway.

December 30, 2004

Tiersten, Lisa Silver_nugget
[HIST BC3321] Colonial Encounters

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

A fairly good course that deals with the concept of empire throughout history, with some profound similarities to the present day. Tiersten is a good lecturer and tries to get the class to participate, which judging by the large size of the class is not always successful. I think a discussion section would have been a good addition to the lectures, but that's just me. She also speaks VERY fast, though you don't really need to get down everything she says. Overall, a pretty good course.

Workload:

Midterm, final, short-ish paper on your own topic. All very reasonable and certainly doable. The reading amount for the class was on the low side, which is always good.

December 07, 2002

Tiersten, Lisa Silver_nugget
[HIST BC3321] Colonial Encounters

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

I would not recommend this class. I took it to fulfill one of the history major requirements and regret it greatly. While the class is incredibly easy even for a Barnard course, the lectures might as well be read out of a textbook. Prof. Tiersten is nice enough, but the lectures are a constant stream of names, facts, and dates that superficially engage with events. Covering Colonial Encounters is a daunting subject, and so instead of focusing on a few events this becomes a survey course with enough information to make one interested in a subject but never enough to make one knowledgable. The course seems geared towards maximizing information for ids for the exams. Further, Tiersten does not know much of the material besides that gotten from textbooks. When talking about Africa for instace, she ignored many significant events in South African history in order to make her explanations seem as clear and logical as possible. Unfortunately, history is not always clear and many factors, not 1 or 2, influence events. This is a simplified history course geared towards memorization. Nobody does the reading and even the TAs are bored, either not showing up or looking out windows. The discussions are even worse with a few students talking and most ignorantly.

Workload:

Very minimal reading, though surprisingly interesting. A very short paper. Two exams based completely on memorization (which she gives you the questions for beforehand). Easy but boring/superficial class with a nice but simplistic professor.

May 20, 2002

Tiersten, Lisa Silver_nugget
[HIST BC3321] Colonial Encounters and [HIST BC1302] European History since 1789

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

Lisa Tiersten may be the best professor you will ever have; not one of the best - THE BEST. She is fascinated with history; she is monumentally enthusiastic; she is an excellent lecturer. She will give you an outline of every lecture complete with ID's which will turn up on the study guide for both mid-terms and finals - so if you do them as you go, you will have half of your studying done by exam-time. You might really want to consider this because her exam-style is to give out prepatory essays and a slew of ID's. If you prepare the essays and the ID's you will do well - that's all there is to it. But there are a lot of essays (between 5 and 7) and ID's (around 50) to prepare. They require a good deal of thought and a really thorough knowledge of lectures, plus some of the text and readings but they show up word for word on the exam - no curve balls. While she does tend to digress, it's only because she can't stand not covering items of interest more thoroughly than she gave herself time to do on the outline. This means that she talks REALLY FAST; it's good to study with others because it's almost impossible to get it all and her lectures are she so interesting that there will be times you simply won't want to be distracted by taking notes. She really cares about her students; wants their input and will be blunt, but never rude, if she doesn't agree. She is probably the world's most popular adviser so her office hours really fill up but she will always make time - just be prepared and realise that, just like class, she will talk fast. I would take any class with this woman. She could probably make tax code exciting. Any class you take you will walk out having been thoroughly grounded in key ideas, read some excellent stuff, seen a few good movies, and , on top of it all, it's impossible not to catch her enthusiam. I wonder how many people she has converted to the major.

Workload:

Reading is fairly light; one short paper, a mid-term and a final. A ton of stuff to study for exams so best to get on it early but otherwise, a fairly light load. A fair grader.

March 15, 2002

Tiersten, Lisa Silver_nugget
[HIST BC3321] Colonial Encounters

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

I enrolled in this class because I needed something to fit in the time slot, and ended up completely loving it despite thinking it was going to be the most boring thing ever. The class was overcrowed but Tiersten managed to know almost everyone's name within the first month. She sometimes seems a bit crazy but her enthusiasm is contangious and she's quite brilliant. If she doesn't know something, she'll return the next class armed with more of an answer than you really wanted. She works hard, cares about her students, has a really good turn around time on grading (which she's quite fair about) and genuinely loves what she teaches. Her lectures are a bit disorganized and she interrupts herself often, but she's easily approchable and does get through the material. I left knowing more than I expected. Seriously, I'd take any class this woman taught and recommend her to anyone. Prior knowledge of history is not required, most of the class knew nothing about history in general. You won't find a bunch of know-it-all history majors here.

Workload:

Midterm, final, three movie screenings and a 5-7 page paper. The paper is open and interesting, and you get review sheets for both exams a week ahead of time. Grading is very fair and there are no discussion sections.

Directory Data

Dept/Subj Directory Course Professor Year Semester Time Section
HSTB / HIST HSTB HIST BC3321: Colonial Encounters Lisa Tiersten 2010 Fall MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1
HSTB / HIST HSTB HIST BC3321: Colonial Encounters Lisa Tiersten 2010 Fall MW / 4:10- 5:25 PM 2
HSTB / HIST HSTB HIST BC3321: Colonial Encounters Lisa Tiersten 2009 Fall MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1
HSTB / HIST HSTB HIST BC3321: Colonial Encounters Lisa Tiersten 2008 Fall MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1
HSTB / HIST HSTB HIST BC3321: Colonial Encounters Lisa Tiersten 2006 Fall MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1
HSTB / HIST HSTB HIST BC3321: Colonial Encounters Lisa Tiersten 2004 Fall MW / 11:00-12:15 PM 1