review comment

Elementary Stochastic Processes

Departments: Statistics

Professors: Mark Brown and Karl Sigman

January 17, 2012

Brown, Mark
Elementary Stochastic Processes

Most reviewers give an accurate sense of this course. I just wanted to add some advice on taking the course--

For the problem sets, Brown will often have "help sessions." Go to these. He basically goes through the entire problem set and does them. I missed the first two, and then was kind of shocked to see him seemingly give away all the answers in the later two. Immensely useful in bringing down the work in the course.

Final and midterm were of the "pick and choose" format. For the midterm, something like 7 questions are given and you pick 4. Don't remember exact numbers, and he may change this. So if you don't have a ton of time to study, you can cram for just a few sections. For the midterm, I just learned all of the Markov chains questions really well and ended up with an okay grade.

To reiterate what others have said: Brown is a very dry lecturer. The main things to know in the course are Markov chains and Exponential Variables / Poisson processes. Everything is built off of one of these two concepts, so just understand these and you'll be fine.

Workload:

Moderate work for problem sets (much less if you attend help sessions). If you're strategic on final and midterm, not much work.

May 17, 2008

Brown, Mark
Elementary Stochastic Processes

This was an interesting class. What you get out of it is entirely a function of what you put in. Lecture is incredibly dry, granted, but the real gold is the posted notes and practice problems.

Stochastic processes are incredibly wonderful things. I've never though so coherently before about series of random processes, but this communicates the subject well.
What's really required here: You need to sit down with the book and the lecture notes and the problem sets and think about Markov chains and Poisson processes on a gut level. Everything else in the course is just an extension or generalization of this.
Become familiar with limit theorems, with the expected values of many distributions and how they relate (for example, the sum of exponentials is just a gamma-- the quotient of two gammas is a beta. etc). There's more than enough practice material to fully ace the exams, there are no tricks on them.

Dr. Brown is a wonderful man, but he injects a formalism into the course that's not needed for the problem sets (that you can do from the book) and is only tangentially needed for the exams (order statistics aren't mentioned in the book, but if you're smart enough, you'll be able to figure out the conditional expectations for the ordering of exponential distributions).

Workload:

Four problem sets, will probably take you a few nights to nail. One midterm and one final. I thought the midterm was more difficult, but I didn't prepare for it adequately-- go through all the practice problems and make sure you can nail them and understand what each step is. This is the exact practice you need for the exams.

May 08, 2006

Brown, Mark
Elementary Stochastic Processes

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

Not a very impressive professor, as he is usually completely oblivious to his students. You can be in the first row with your hand raised, and he would just stare right past you and never call on you. Lectures are quite dry and quasi-mathematically rigorous, so it may be easy to fall behind occasionally. Otherwise, the subject matter is interesting and rewarding. I don't know how it is different from 4106 or 3106 though. It doesn't seem to be much higher in level. I think the previous reviewer did a good job scaring off most people, but it's not that bad.

Workload:

5 problem sets, about 5-6 hours each. easy midterm. harder final.

May 12, 2005

Brown, Mark
Elementary Stochastic Processes

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

Holy freakin bejeezus.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Be not fooled by the word "Elementary" in this course's title. This is THE hardest class in Columbia, without qualification. Ever. I can't believe I made it out alive. Unfortunately for Mark, the subject material is perhaps the hardest branch of statistics, in terms of intuition and concepts. He tries very very hard to make sense of it to us, but hopelessly so. No mistake, I think Mark would have been a decent teacher in another class. But in general, I think he's on a totally different level than the rest of the class. Problems seem easy when he solves them, but come homework, there is no way students would be able to complete them without his hints.

I don't want to scare any potential stat majors, but the mean on the midterm was around 30 or 40. If you can't handle the heat of this course (which is actually graduate level) then take the much easier undergraduate engineering version. However, if you have the mathematical maturity and persistence to learn everything that is taught, then the world is yours -- just kidding, but it's still very interesting stuff.

Workload:

Biweekly problem sets, nearly impossible midterm and final. Godspeed.

May 29, 2002

Sigman, Karl Silver_nugget
Elementary Stochastic Processes

Please keep in mind that this review is more than 5 years old.

Here's the review for Intro to OR: Stochastic Models, which should be relevant because Sigman is teaching Elementary Stichastic Processes in the fall, which should be pretty similar. Excellent teacher! great class. Definitely the most interesting lecturer I've had for a math related class, and he makes difficult probability concepts fairly straightforward and understandable. You get the feeling that he enjoys teaching and really tries hard to get everyone to understand everything. Highly recommended.

Workload:

Weekly problem sets which could be difficult sometimes but nothing overwhelming, and it's only a few problems a week. Midterm and final which aren't difficult if you've been keeping up with classes, homework and the practice midterma and final.

Directory Data

Dept/Subj Directory Course Professor Year Semester Time Section
STAT / STAT STAT STAT W4606: Elementry Stochastic Processes Michael Hogan 2012 Spring TR / 7:40- 8:55 PM 1
STAT / STAT STAT STAT W4606: Elementry Stochastic Processes Mark Brown 2012 Fall MW / 6:10- 7:25 PM 1
STAT / STAT STAT STAT W4606: Elementry Stochastic Processes El Hammou 2010 Spring TR / 6:10- 7:25 PM 1
STAT / STAT STAT STAT W4606: Elementry Stochastic Processes Victor Pena 2010 Fall MW / 6:10- 7:25 PM 1
STAT / STAT STAT STAT W4606: Elementry Stochastic Processes Michael Hogan 2009 Spring MW / 6:10- 7:25 PM 1
STAT / STAT STAT STAT W4606: Elementry Stochastic Processes Mark Brown 2009 Fall MW / 6:10- 7:25 PM 1
STAT / STAT STAT STAT W4606: Elementry Stochastic Processes Mark Brown 2008 Fall MW / 6:10- 7:25 PM 1